People don't sell the clean offer for lower than 9 keys.This is steadily rising in price. The uncraft should easily be 5 keys. Upvoted.

Agreed. Only 27% of All-Fathers are uncraftable and its harder to find these on sale. Sellers will most likely try to bump up the price because of the Winter season and buyers are happy to pay more because its a very popular misc and don't mind having it dirty.