Suggestion: Haunted Executioner at 1.5–2 keys

Price Suggestion

~1.28 keys

202 votes up

88 votes down

Related Suggestions

This suggestion was closed Wed, 14 Nov 12 14:31:49 +0000 by Puddilicious.

Comments can no longer be left on this suggestion.

Comments

I completely agree. Haunteds found in Eerie Crates are due to SKYROCKET in price soon.

i get the feeling ur saying that coz thats pretty much all u own

they are kinda like the new genuines, you can't get them in that quality anymore and they rise a little over time (not "soon"), but that is far from skyrocketing

Except not at all. Its just hype. People said the same thing about strange rainblowers and theyve decreased in value since the crate stopped dropping.

Have you not noticed what happened with the B.M.O.C. and Ebenezer, they dropped for a little bit a small amount then started rising again. They are also Holiday items. Crone Dome and Executioner, (Genuine of course), will be Holiday Items also. When Halloween comes around next year, I can see these being in the 12-15 key range.

your logic is flawed, the only way to get a Ebenezer or BMOC is to get a unique one, there are no others, so people invested in them making them skyrocket in a speculating bubble, when it comes to haunted, look at the genuines, you can get an uncraftable and a crafted version of them, so people that want it cheap can still have it, people that want the fancy cyan text have to look for a haunted, as I said, they will slowly go up in price, but far from skyrocket as much as you guys seem to think

You are basing your assumption on the condition that "I" said skyrocket even once. I never said it would skyrocket, but I did say it will rise. I also never said the Ebenezer and B.M.O.C. came in any other versions. However, the Haunted version is available only via an Eerie Crate, which as you know by now, is expired.

And whatever the deal is on the uncraftable and crafted versions of them, they are completely irrelevant in this price suggestion. Please learn to understand this person was suggesting a price on the Haunted one and not in the item as a whole for all versions.

wont be soon, wont be a skyrocket. by the time next october rolls around, expect them to be worth more, but it's like vintage hats, slow rise over time because of a limited number made, same or diminishing demand

have to agree, 2 keys seem to be the norm

Since there are still some unsold, so 1.5-2 seems legit

All old trades, all unsold for 2 keys. Downvote.

I don't understand your logic:

Link1 - Macas Sold to One within last 2 days

Link4 - Pew Pew sold to Stark

Link2 - Some rubbish

So, 2Links sold for 2 keys, 2Link unsold, 1 Link to nowhere.... Overall 50% of the proofs shows 2keys. Or are you overlooking something?

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/5719798 , http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/6044375 , http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/5594104 , http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/6171479 - All sold for 2 keys

most of those were from 2 weeks ago, only 1 of those links shows one selling for 2 keys from this week.

I don't know about other trades but I managed to sell this item about 4 days ago for ~5 ref (3.66 ref + craft hat): [url]http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/6112121[/url]

I went and bought a black painted one for 3 keys afterwards, which is why there's one in my BP at the moment. Check item IDs to verify.

Edit: well, something strange is up, the buyer seems to have a different one at the moment, and it looks like I never sold that hat to him at all. I'm going to have to look into this more, but in the meantime: [url]http://i.imgur.com/At2yo.jpg[/url]

completely agree

None of the links have sold, I'm pretty unconvinced.

I personally think the Executioner should continue raising in price for a little while. Considering it is an all class, awesome-looking, Haunted Halloween Hat similar to the Crone Dome, I think it should actually raise in price due to being a Halloween Special. Understanding many things are Halloween specials, (achieved during Halloween only), this hat along with the Crone Dome are not LIMITED to Halloween or Halloween Mode only.

I will upvote this as I think it should raise in price and be one of the 2 Halloween versions of the Ebenezer and B.M.O.C.

Ebenezer - Executioner

B.M.O.C. - Crone Dome

This is my personal opinion.

This isn't the right way to cast votes on these things. You should either a) have bought or sold this item or b) have seen some evidence of trades.

One big Problem is, there are too many people who vote without actually looking at evidence. Most just vote based on what prices they prefer or speculate to be.

Some even post passing comments like "All are unsold" without even checking item ID (items did change hands) or validating price knowledge of buyer/seller (they might be new players who doesn't know the price)

We can only rely on the mods to keep the integrity of prices.

I do check the prices for your information. How about not making assumptions. However, unlike many other voters, like those who make such assumptions, I do not vote based on some simple sales. I also watch market trends and figure out patterns. Which is why I posted the B.M.O.C./Ebenezer comparison.

I didnt blindly vote, I honestly think that the price on this SHOULD be raised.

Sorry if you think i am targeting your post or you, I am not

I was just making a general statement on voters,

Just using this thread for example, there are already,

- false discredits of proofs

- speculative post on prices (skyrocket)

Luckily there wasn't any fabricated proofs... and hopefully there will not be.

It doesn't matter whether you think the price of an item should rise, it matters whether the item is selling in large quantities at the price suggestion you suggested right now, not in three weeks, not in three months, today.

And it is. I was looking at the trades on Outpost and it is selling. I just put in my personal thoughts as well. But I mean if you cannot be professional and see through that, be my guest.

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/5886194 : Wants 2 keys, 1 key offer. Trade is one week old

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/5800657 : Asks 2 keys, no offers. One week old trade

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/6078697 : One week old, asks for 2 key 1 Ref. No offers.

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/5853717 : Recent offer of one key, one week old trade. (When trade was first opened, someone offered 2 keys on it, but this is old data)

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/6216486 : Sold for 2.77 Ref.

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/6266425 : 1.5 keys, no offers (and according to OP suggestion, this should be Quickselling at that price!)

I could keep on adding links, but they all look the same. In trades including many haunted items, the Executioner doesn't have any offers on it. Before trying to slander me get your information right.