Suggestion: Disco Beat Down Milkman at 46.25 keys

Price Suggestion

Disco Beat Down Milkman

Submitted Sat, 26 Apr 14 06:33:55 +0000 by ★ DLH

83.13%

n/a

46.25 keys

~44.5 keys

dbd

266 votes up

54 votes down

Related Suggestions

This suggestion was marked as bad evidence and closed Fri, 09 May 14 16:57:14 +0000 by Horizon.

There should always be enough evidence to back up the new proposed value. However, it appears that the evidence is not strong enough, or cherry-picked in a way that does not represent the actual market value of the item. Therefore, this suggestion has been closed.

Comments can no longer be left on this suggestion.

Comments

Drip that milk *chaos ensues*

Lawsooooooon soundtrack this time, gonna make a quick flat price for this little unu. Really want that Nunhood below D:

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/19407591

Sold for an O.Fire Nunhood

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/18784935

Sold for 2.5 pure

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/17697177

Sold for a DP Wraith Wrap (2.8 buds original value)

Total: 2.5 buds after overpay calculation

Conclusion: Well. Um. Yeah. Constructive criticism and counter proof always appreciated :3

DBD < Miami Nights, for sure?

sarcasm? or?...

That's why the market is the unusual market is so complex, people have different opinions about effects .. i for one dislike any heart effects and think they're completely overpriced.

Ok so im just thinking here, but, you are telling us DBD is worth less than searing plasma and equal to flies? Also one was listed as a QS at 3 buds (who seemed quick to accept 2.5) and the other guy had his open for a ~1 week and sold for a dead pres wraith wrap which at the time was 4.7-5. I don't think this represents the market for this hat correctly. >_>

Also of the 5 for sale at the moment the b/os are: 6 buds, 6 buds, 7 buds, offers, 6 buds.

Edit: Also i unboxed the O.fire nunhood and sold it to iz gud for his roboactive hermes, he then traded the O. fire nunhood for the Milkman because he thought it was a safe 6+ buds

Don't know if you can tell, but im down voting on this QS price and miss use of a sale

Some rejected offers taken from the milkman trades:

Terror Watt Cold Killer for the Milkman (4-4.1)

DBD Capotain (~3.5bud) + Pro Kunai Kit (Incinerator, Emerald) + Spec Scatter Kit (Daffodil) + Spec Knife Kit + 5 ready spec kits + 1 bud?

UNusual Metal Slug Effect Terror Wat for Milk man

GBH Virtual Reality Headset for the Milkman

war pig aces high for the milkman?

infernal impaler c9 for milkman

All taken from ONE TRADE: http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/18053548

Noted. Will see what the mods think of this. Meanwhile, I'll look to add more proof. May resuggest due to this. Thx for the help

I hate to be a drag man, but its wrong and im looking out for a friend. Also when this is priced i can price my O.fire nunhood.

lern2edit

I could have edited and made a giant comment, but i was proving different things in different comments. At least i edited in the note of how i was related xD

Paragraphs ^^

This is still open? //sigh// Well iz gud sold his DbD Milkman for a miami tyrants helm, which is also unpriced..

Its fact that this proof isnt solid, a QS and new price (2 weeks ago) on a 2 month trade is misleading.

Do i need to get more offers to prove this range is wrong or will you save your own rep and close this suggest?

I don't know whether to cry or laugh that this is still open. Mods prove me wrong, show me the flaws in the comments or just close this suggestion.

Also this is the guy iz gud sold the milkman to & the hat he traded for : http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/19434407

Didn't have time to add it earlier, but i'm sure its worth more than 2.5 buds.

So are we clear the sales are invalid because one was on the 16th of feb for an unusual worth 4.7-5 at the time and one was a listed QS who accepted the first pure offer which was half a bud under? (it should be noted that creeves bought this QS and is still selling this hat for offers?)

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/18976304 - Sold for 50 keys (2.6 buds)

Castiels proof of the offers are abit outdated considering that the hype of the new effects are decreasing and all offers that he mentioned were new effects. 2.5 buds is close enough, upvote :D

He will need to resuggest with better proof, he can use creeves sale but i still think everyone is insane on this suggest. >_>

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/19490341 - they made the deal here.

I was offered this the other day on my Miami Nights Lucha + Stormy Storm Drill hat. Guy said "they sell for 7 easily" BAH LIE. Glad I didnt' take it.

Still 2.5 is REALLY low for a DBD and a Milkman at that.

Most of the offers shown in the comments here are irrelevant since they are >1 month old and the value on these new effect hats are moving targets. However, there are some recent offers higher than 2.5 that raise concern

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/19502593 - caribou ~2.7 after overpay made yesterday

As for pure offers, this owner rejected 3 pure about 2 months ago - http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/18331058. That is admittedly old.

I think a more conservative range of 2.5-3 would be better.

Using an old rejected offer for the high end tho? Two dif sales maybe determines just a 2.5 flat, we could just watch and see whether they go above 3 in the future with a set price. Thx for the comment tho :)

So are you closing this now or what? cmon man the range and proof is all wrong, make him resuggest or get someone else to do it. Either that or wait.

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/18784935 - Sold for 2.5 pure

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/19490341 - resold for 2,5 pure on a qs trade again (possible chain of quicksales?)

I agree that 2.5 flat doesn't reflect the price of this hat very good, closing, needs more proof overall.~

Trades open at the moment:

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/18331058 No B/O or notes

Rejected offers:

roboactive madame dixie (5 days ago)

Kill-a-Watt Stout Shako (Aust. Gold) 1/1 on Market, but Terror-Watt one is about 3 buds. (4 days ago)

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/19681691 fresh baby QS for 4 buds pure, made 3 hours ago at time of comment

Watch this space!!

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/16386836 B/O of 6 pure still

Rejected offers:

could u add a few buds for my stahlhelm? (dbd) (april 24th)

dbd whoopee (painted purple) + 1 key (april 13th)

SO sales I found:

dbd milkman for http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/19434407 (unpriced and said before i know, but juicy.)

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/19677580 sold for??

And le copy and paste:

So really, why the fuck is this still open? At least someone re suggest with better proof. >_>