Suggestion: Darkblaze Hot Dogger at 56.88–65 keys

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/19711072 - Duped, sold for an Aces High Das Maddendoktor (~3.2 buds, outdated price) + Clean Horseless Headless Horseman's Head (~0.6-0.7 buds)

I traded my Darkblaze Powdered Practitioner (unpriced) for: This hat (3.5-4 buds?) + a Stormy 13th Hour Conquistador (2.8 buds, outdated price) + a gifted Flaming Lantern Birdcage (~3.1 buds, gifted tag, outdated price) = total of ~8 buds.

Keep in mind that all of these offers were made on duped versions of this hat. It is possible that clean versions might get more valuable offers.

Dupes aren't valid proof, and even then you only have one sale and you need two for an unpriced unusual.

You need 2 solds to create a new price :)

Thanks guys! I've updated the post. I must've missed it somehow.

The fact that all of these are duped means none of them are valid. It also surprises me that you never showed what you bought yours for? Perhaps price manipulation?

I'll update what I bought it for right away! :)

Also, why would dupes not work as valid? They literally have no disabilities!

Dupes are the same as clean ones in-game but it makes the hat less rare.

Duped items sell for less than their counter-part, the clean ones which does not reflect accurately on the real price of a hat.

Since there is only duped ones on the market as of now, and most likely will always be until another one is unboxed, I believe this to be a reasonable price. I even raised the price slightly because I believed clean ones to sell for about 0.3 buds more! :)

You can't just assume clean ones go for 0.3 buds, that's just an approximation. I'd wait.

This hat needs a price tag though, and since this is a Halloween effect it might never be unboxed again, leaving only duped ones left for sale! The thought for duped items is dying out and so is duping itself. Now, I'm not saying duping is a good thing but it just doesn't matter as much as it used to.

if the proof isn't there this suggestion will have to wait

"Unpriced/gifted/duped hats - do not assume prices or take a fixed subtraction based off the clean versions of hats. "

http://forums.backpack.tf/index.php?/topic/6033-new-unusual-price-suggestion-guide-the-cheat-sheet/

As I mentioned earlier there might never be a clean version of this hat for sale, ever. :)

The clean one has been on the market not too long ago (3 months)

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/18564792 - sold for phos pipe ~1.8?

Your high end is also coming from outdated hats that will need to be updated first before pricing this. I'm not necessarily opposed to pricing this off the duped since those sales are higher than the clean one, but you need to apply proper overpay and to follow the rules shown here: http://forums.backpack.tf/index.php?/topic/6033-new-unusual-price-suggestion-guide-the-cheat-sheet/