Suggestion: Arcana Fruit Shoot at 60.8 keys

Price Suggestion

Arcana Fruit Shoot

Submitted Wed, 13 Aug 14 17:59:31 +0000 by ★ Burpman

83.5%

60–86 keys

60.8 keys

~1100 keys

arcana

167 votes up

33 votes down

Related Suggestions

This suggestion was closed Sat, 30 Aug 14 01:24:25 +0000 by polar.

Comments can no longer be left on this suggestion.

Comments

COUNTERSUGGESTERINO

GBH LED ( http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/21613297 ) (3.5*0.9=3.2)

Phos Nickel (4.2) - 1 pure ( http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/21600834 ) (3.2)

Proof that the phos nickel sale included 1 pure:

http://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198072051577?time=1406703600

http://backpack.tf/item/113881626

Copypasted a bit of the old one, but we can't have invalid proof can we?

you are doing it again ...

pricing the fruit with the nickel and the nickel with the fruit

don't you get it,that one of the suggestions shouldn't have the trade in it ?

It's not the same thing, really. For this one, I'm simply correcting the old proof. See http://backpack.tf/vote/id/53e2c2044ed7b8642f8b463e

The older suggestion got by with the same proof, why shouldn't this? And he only made a mini for the nickel; I've done a full suggestion.

x-1=y

y+1=x

x=nickel

y=fruit

that's exactly what you are doing (well that + you take overpay,which further complicates things. but the point is,you can't do that)

You're ignoring my point. The old suggestion got accepted yet the proof was invalid, I'm simply correcting it. Take a step back and ignore my nickel for now. The old one got by with just a mini for the nickel.

exactly

but you have only 2 sales on the nickel suggestion. (and one seems to be an outlier)

you can't use the fruit to price it

but you can use the nickel to price the fruit. (implying you get 2 valid sales on the nickel)

So if I can use the nickel to price the fruit, it should be possible to price the nickel using the fruit afterwards, yeah?

the nickel is sold for 5 potatoes,and for 4.5 potatoes

you make a suggestion for 4.5-5

the fruit is sold for a gbh led which is 3 potatoes

and it was traded + 1 potato for the nickel = 3.75 potatoes

just for show,using rough (made up values).

you need another sale for the nickel,which doesn't include a arcana fruit shot

edit: looking back,it would look better with apples,after all it's a fruit shoot sugg. <,<

yeah i kind of get the point, though this can hold weight on its own

remember, this is just a correction of invalid proof

true. but you have to price the nickel right to correct it.

and you have only 1 valid sale with the nickel.

so basically...

you can't price the nickel

but you can make a new suggestion for the fruit shot,

where you show 1 bud was added with the fruit. making a mini for the nickel (4.5)

that way you'll make a 3.2-3.5 range on the fruit

boom,corrected

http://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198062565400?time=1408258800 - burning bat bone dome + aussie FJ?

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/22049932 - b/o was 4 though, so no more than 4. outlier?

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/21786435 - phos dragon born - duped (unpriced); later sold for a demonflame bone dome (also unpriced)

I think a conservative drop of 3.2-4 would be better.