Suggestion: Arcana Executioner at 310 keys

Price Suggestion

~1900 keys

arcana

62 votes up

58 votes down

Related Suggestions

This suggestion was closed Wed, 04 Nov 15 21:08:24 +0000 by the submitter.

Comments can no longer be left on this suggestion.

Comments

Sold for 320 keys overpay, bought by me. Proof: http://prntscr.com/8w0okr

Seller bp before: https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198055358018?time=1445670000

Seller bp after: https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198055358018?time=1445929200

320? Then why is the suggestion 310?

Because I paid 320 keys in overpay, not pure. So the pure price should be like 310~ keys.

No need to apply overpay if the purchase was 100% pure.

Doesn't look like it is, unless I'm jsut blind or something, it looks like there's some small unusual and item overpay in there.

But Unusuals were never my strong spot. so..

Except it wasn't all pure, check the proof. And, though I haven't checked, I'm willing to bet one or more of the unusuals involved is out of date and needs a mini.

Did a whole suggestion on how his guess in price was actually right on below you, lol

you can't just pull out a random number. use the overpay multiplier (0.9)

Did a whole suggestion on how his guess in price was actually right on, look below you, lol

Lol never mind then

His calculation at 310 was actually right on, here is all the proof.

Sale #1

Sold for 100 keys pure + B. Flames Larrikin (61.5) + HG Mann of Reason (43) + Screaming Tiger Taunt: I see you (33.5) + S. Pro. KS Aussie Scatter (44) + Roboactive Buckaroos Hat (45) + Strange Mutated Milk w/ part (1.95) + S. Spark of Life Medi gun (4)

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198055358018?time=1445670000

10/24 - 10/27

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/27242975 - no B/O

61.5 + 43 + 33.5 + 44 + 45 + 1.95 + 4 = 233*0.9 = 210 + 100 = 310

-------------------------->

310 keys for this sale

-------------------------->

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Minis:

S. Pro. KS Aussie Scatter: 44 keys (going with majority)

https://backpack.tf/classifieds?item=Scattergun&quality=11&tradable=1&craftable=1&australium=1&killstreak_tier=3 - only counting ones that aren’t gifted, aren’t QSing, and don’t have many parts

1x 42

1x 42.5

4x 44

2x 45

2x 50

Roboactive Buckaroos Hat: 45 keys

Sold for 45 keys pure (wow)

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198054789800?time=1442082660 9/12 - 9/17

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/25707079 - I love people who show what it sold for, no B/O

45 keys for this sale

S. Spark of Life Medi gun: 4 keys

http://steamcommunity.com/market/listings/440/Strange%20Spark%20of%20Life%20Medi%20Gun%20%28Minimal%20Wear%29 - had a few sales around $8 for a while

2x 7.95 (Oct. 17 and 18)

1x $8 (Oct. 19)

2x $7.98 (Oct. 20 and 22)

1x $8.04 (Oct. 20)

1x $8.08 (Oct. 20)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Even though I did all the minis and all for you, it's an upvote from me. You're welcome btw.

Nice one on getting the info for it. But imo this should be closed and put up again by somebody who knows how to suggest (Zenith.) Fact is, Wonky got lucky with his random price suggestion. Getting lucky shouldn't qualify for the reputation points on this and having somebody else do all the work. It sets a bad example.

If he had been off the mark then everyone would have been all over him about reading the suggestion rules etc.

That's up to the mods to decide, but I don't really care, I just like helping people out :)

No harm in helping people out as long as the person suggesting has done a great deal of work to try and provide proof. But you cant deny that this was pulled out of thin air from an opinion (320 keys overpay means its worth 310.....no...it doesnt. 320 overpay would be 288 if all was items. Even the 100 keys would have put it at 298) If the Buckaroo hadnt have been sold for a high pure price then 310 would not have been correct.

Technically, as long as the suggested value is okay, it does not matter who suggested it or in what way

Much like this here: http://backpack.tf/vote/id/5605a575dea9e95d0f8b456f

I guess in this case its even better than in the example since the suggested price is more exact :P

Sorry to nitpick but: https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198096864117?time=1441868400 9/10 - 9/19 only 40 keys removed

If you use the same link and change to 09/12 - 09/13 you see more clearly and can confirm in the histories that the keys went to Groovypanda for his Screaming Tiger I see You

Yes but in the pic he provided the sale was the sale from steam inventory history http://prntscr.com/8w0okr

And even then, the outpost said clearly he did a trade for 45 right after they did the trade http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/25707079

It was 45 keys clearly.

I am just confused why there is no record of 45 keys. According to bp.tf, all those keys belonged to dtn before moose. I would want to see a pic confirming the trade for the buckaroo. This could also be used to update the buckaroo's price.

It looks like a few of the unusuals you used have outdated prices so you would need to do minis for those. Also overpay is x0.9.

Did a whole suggestion on how his guess in price was actually right on, look above you, lol

Yup just read it! Nice work. Now I wonder if OP actually did all that work and just failed to show it or just used outdated numbers and made random decisions on overpay percentage that somehow lead to the correct number.

God damn, I'm lucky I checked this suggestion before blind downvoting.

Lol you're welcome