Suggestion: Stormy Storm Sheriff's Stetson at 40 keys

Price Suggestion

~27 keys

stormy

111 votes up

8 votes down

Related Suggestions

This suggestion was closed Fri, 01 Jul 16 14:23:49 +0000 by the submitter.

Comments can no longer be left on this suggestion.

Comments

Sold:

http://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198110659881#!/compare/1461542400/1461628800 - sold for Flaming Lantern Physician's Protector = 40 keys

http://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198007850070#!/compare/1461456000/1461542400 - sold for Blizzardy Storm One-Man Army = low

Seems to have resold for 26 keys

http://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198045366924#!/compare/1466812800/1466899200

http://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198003223998#!/compare/1466035200/1467072000 [only shows 21 but quite sure it was 26, especially since the comment show a 25-26 offer that the seller seemed to be interested in. That offer was retracted but it would support it was 26 rather than 21]

what do you suggest is better?

in all honesty I think the lantern phys is too high at 40 flat (which is why I left this up for so long in the first place :P). The person that got the phys for the stetson instantly resold his phys for a DaD gonzila (33). Arguably 'low' given how fast he did so, but its an indication of what he expected out of his stetson. Since 40 is in-date (and definitely was when the trade happened) I guess you can use that, though.

Secondary concern for me here is that the 26 pure sale is actually a middle ground here; as its equally far off the gym rat as it is from the physician. I was initially going to suggest you to redo this at 26-40 with the notice that 40 is probably on the high side, but Im getting second thoughts here. Ill ask another mod for a second opinion here.

ok let me know if you think the range or 26 flat would be better :)

Well the Physician could always have a new suggestion up at either 33-40 or 33 flat, depends on what you think is better, since most of the sales at 40 are either outdated by now or close to be outdated.

A range of 26-33 or 26-37 wouldn't be that bad for a hat like this.

As for the One-Man Army sale, that sale could probably be disregarded in any case here, if the 18 Key buyer and the $45 SCM buy orders are of any indication. :P

Foamy, I'm dissapointed you didn't consult me about this since I'm on your list :< I paid 26 keys pure keys, aswell as $15 via paypal. Not to mention I got it at a discount from a close friend of mine.

http://i.imgur.com/yo6yH0q.png

Thanks, that will bring the sale to about ~34, which is probably far closer to what the lantern phys should be.

This can now be redone at 34 flat

what about the actual sale? screenshot is only of $15

http://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198003223998#!/compare/1466035200/1467072000

i only see 21 keys, will need proof of 26

the rest of the keys are visible in the buyer's perspective, which shows 26 keys that leave the backpack and match the seller