Suggestion: Starstorm Slumber Winter Woodsman at 42–47 keys

2. They can sell for whatever they want (shooting star / reggae), doesn't mean I shouldn't be using a sale for a mini here. I used a recent sale at the time of the suggestion that I could find without it being a qs. Why use sellers when you have sales?

Having said that, Im not sure its worth resugging. With your fixes (11 on shooting star and 18 on reggae), range would be 40-50, which widens the gap to 10 keys. Plus there is that seller on the classies at 36 rn listed for 15 days already, I would think it's worth waiting 10 more days to use it as the low end.

He couldn't have owned it since January because it was untradable several days before the sale.

The reggae is most likely going to be lower than 18 keys, I'd suggest finding a new mini. I have a sale that should cap at my B/O of 15, but I can't help for about 12 hours from now.

http://backpack.tf/item/5226060334

he got it 23rd of January though? The sale I provided is the 25/26th of April when he sold it. even then, with a 7 day (which there wouldnt have been cause he didnt unbox it), its Jan 30th.

No, it was listed on the SCM on the 23rd of January. 23rd of January was when it was last seen in the user's backpack, not when a sale occurred.

I can't seem to find what date he actually DID obtain it supposedly from the SCM. Can I see the proof for that?

and to be honest idk why Im debating a sale thats obviously way too low regardless but whatever.

Also if the reggae is, say, 15, that brings the bottom to 37, high end 50. Sarting to get a tad big for its price level. Usually 15 key ranges under 50 keys are stupidly large. Having said that, waht would I use then? ~~68-70?~~ (just realized that be dumb if it sold 3 times under that level by a mile) and where does the 36 unsold fall in yet?

http://www.tf2outpost.com/trade/28890182 - untradable, created on the 23rd of April.

A range of 36-50 (or 35-50) really isn't that bad, though I would probably wait for more sales.