Suggestion: Stare from Beyond Counterfeit Billycock at 24–47 keys

Price Suggestion

stare

40 votes up

37 votes down

This suggestion was closed Fri, 15 Dec 17 20:48:45 +0000 by Vijf Kilo Boter (met voetjes).

Comments can no longer be left on this suggestion.

Comments

Range makes me vomit but considering the ooze is 26 and indate, thought first sale should be included

Sale 1: https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198048492330#!/compare/1509408000/1509494400

Sold for 24 pure, doesn't seem like a qs as guy had it for a month

Sale 2:

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198142949496#!/compare/1510444800/1510531200

Sold for atomic universal translator and 20 keys pure. Currently in a collector's BP so not going anywhere soon

Sale 3: https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198090547538#!/compare/1501286400/1501372800

Sold for holy Grail obliterated, (52.5) but sellers at 29/30. Hasn't sold yet and has active suggestion at 28.

https://backpack.tf/suggestion/59ff2f7acf6c755e507ed84a

Other unusual: https://backpack.tf/item/3120579802

In collector's bp

First of all, you did not advise the other guy how to make the suggestion proper, you seem to just want the credit for it. 16 minutes for a counter? Nah fam.

Second, 24-47 is way too big for this price and needs a 3rd sale to find the outlier. Im betting its the 47 but whatever.

agreed on the range, but as to the counter thing the other guy didn't provide half the proof that the counter provides :u

Right. So you give it to him....... didn't offer him the chance to fix it, and are trying to take the credit.

well this isn't my suggestion so I'm not trying to take credit for anything. if your counter puts in more work than the original, I see no reason to give the work to the original suggester and not just use the work yourself. but anyways, this is getting off topic

(don't get me wrong though, this doesn't mean you shouldn't explain/give some advice to the original)

1. sorry I assumed you were OP, removed "you" after I noticed

2. If its REALLY bad then okay but he at least tried to show and was asking questions like "thats not how you do it, is it?" so better to advise than just shut down

I found a third sale, can't mini it apart from the active suggestion, fits inside the range.

assuming active suggestion is good, sale 3 clearly shows 47 is an outlier.

Okay 26 is just too low. I know thats what the ooze is priced at, but one of them isn't even selling it for 26. https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198076020691 "Only looking for really good offer!"

edit: actually wait what unusual are you talking about :?

Well it's an indate price so despite it not being on market, its usable

I should probably just make one for 47, no range.

47 isn't including the other sales, either this should be priced at 24-47 using all sales or 24-28 using the 2 lower ones if the 47 sale is deemed an outlier

24 is definitely a quicksale

Who said anything about the number 24?

sale 1

Inconvenient as it may be, the sales here are simply too far apart. We can't just dismiss the 24 sale because it was an alledged quicksale; we don't know that.

The most annoying part here is the taunt sale that - at old value - supported high end, and at it's new value, supports the low end (it sold with some sweets, by the way). So that really doesn't help. That means that we're left with the most plausible common trading point in pure, and the most recent sale to a collector that won't resell, which heavily contradict each other.

After discussion with the other moderators, we've decided that this is best left unpriced due to the lack of stability in selling value.