The first sale is ridiculously low, sharking levels low, especially for a 1/1 pumpkin moon. I will show you what I paid (second sale) and what I sold it for (third sale).

What I paid for the Bazaar Bauble with Pumpkin Moon:

Pumpkin Moon Airdog + 3 keys pure + Unusualifier for the tracksmans. ( http://prntscr.com/1yrpi6q )

At the time Pumpkin Moon Airdogs were listed for about 100-120 keys and the Unusualifier would sell for about 3 keys.

- Mini for the airdog:

I got the Pumpkin Moon Airdog + Strange Bedouin Bandana + Dead Head for my Pumpkin Moon Shutterbug ( http://prntscr.com/1yrpcp5 )

Basically saw this as the Airdog with Pumpkin Moon + 55 pure keys.

- - Mini for the Pumpkin Moon Shutterbug:

I paid 80 keys straight to the unboxer. Shutterbug with Pumpkin Moon is still 1/1 and hasnt had any other sales besides this one and the Airdog one. ( http://prntscr.com/1yrp8w5 )

What I sold the Bazaar Bauble for:

95 keys pure + maxhead ( https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198056086416#!/compare/1635552000/1635638400 )

95 + 27 = 122 keys (pure value, no unsellable or overpriced items involved)

45 keys pure for this 1/1 Pumpkin Moon Bazaar Bauble is sharking levels low. In the current market this would sell for 100-130 pure without much trouble.

If anyone else wants to make lots of price suggestions hit me up. I owned roughly 25 eyes of molten / pumpkin moon unusuals and can provide screenshots of all sales.