We only have one side's perspective of the breakdown of item valuations for this sale (AncientPear, https://imgur.com/a/DCkV6DX). Because of this it is possible for AncientPear to have manipulated the valuations in his favor, especially considering he still owns the Lucky Shot.

Usually in cases like these we require confirmation of the item valuations from both parties or a chat screenshot of the valuations. I don't see a reason for this suggestion to break the rule, so unfortunately this suggestion will need to be closed.