Suggestion: Cloudy Moon Company Man at 657 keys

Price Suggestion

~525 keys

moon

41 votes up

19 votes down

Related Suggestions

This suggestion was closed automatically because another price suggestion was accepted instead.

Comments can no longer be left on this suggestion.

Comments

upd.

1.this + keys for Knifestorm Scotch Bonnet

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198132327367#!/compare/1702598400/1702684800

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198158206236#!/compare/1702598400/1702684800

2.Spelled sold for Otherworldly Weather Mean Captain (283k) + Non-Craftable Specialized Killstreak Rocket Launcher Kit (~3) + Tesla Coil Tough Stuff Muffs(138k) + Frostbite Big Elfin Deal (outdate price, only one sale / bo 80k) + Scorching Flames Winter Woodsman (148k) + Aurora Polaris Taunt: The Carlton (can't price - use bo 5k) - 657k

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198174890191#!/compare/1701475200/1701561600

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198092169522#!/compare/1701475200/1701561600

3.bulk

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198092169522#!/compare/1702252800/1702339200

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198063640894#!/compare/1702166400/1702339200

4.bulk

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198063640894#!/compare/1702771200/1702857600

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198036241064#!/compare/1701561600/1702857600

5.Gravelly Ghoul All Hallows' Hatte + Strange Scorching Flames Tundra Top(can't use - only bulk sales)

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198036241064#!/compare/1703376000/1703548800

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198285371555#!/compare/1703462400/1703548800

6.Molten Mallard Hong Kong Cone + Sunbeams Scotsman's Stove Pipe (can't update https://backpack.tf/suggestion/65b934d36486fe633a06c57f)

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198285371555#!/compare/1703894400/1703980800

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198024223746#!/compare/1703808000/1703894400

t: 657k

I do not know if it is possible to use sales of spelled things, however, doing this for vvf before, mods did not have any questions. Correct me if I'm wrong.

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198024223746#!/compare/1706832000/1706918400 - 280 Keys + GE HKC (225 Keys) + Sunbeams HWNN (220 Keys)

Sale 6 also included the Tesla Coil Toadstool Topper and 190 Keys.

The Toadstool has a mini for it here - https://backpack.tf/suggestion/6626a6cd4c3e0f9ef50bdcfe - at 118. The Stove is also 100 Keys there.

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198024223746#!/compare/1703808000/1703894400 - 122 of these Keys were for the Pith Helmet

https://backpack.tf/profiles/76561198085556501#!/compare/1703808000/1703894400 - The Pith sale

That'd make sale 6 actually 590 Keys here.

In summary, the spelled sales are 590, 657, and 725 while the non-spelled one added 175 Keys for something with another sale at 645 Keys.

As such, the spelled sales should be treated differently from the non-spelled sales in this case. 470 would work here.

idk about this, ur basically saying spelled and non spelled are equal value here which i disagree. The 657k sale was spelled, the knife bonnet sale was unspelled, so now the bonnet gets updated using spelled sale?

The spelled also sold for 480 keys at one point, and quite a few of these sales don’t seem to be on the level of the 657 sale.

A ghoul hatte and a strange scorching all class arent 650 keys, u just priced the hatte at like 220-270

The mallard hkc is in date at like 240, ur stovepipe suggestion was 85-100, making that sale like 350 MAX

downvote, I do not agree with this assessment at all.

This is correct. If there has been recent sales, even if unusuable, you cannot price something using spelled ones. If the spelled one was the one involved in the trade that you are using this as a mini you can use it over there but cannot suggest its price as it could possibly be higher or lower than what the regular non-spelled one could go for, otherwise you'll have to mark this sale as unusuable on whatever you were trying to price and either close everything or resuggest accordingly!

Seeing its a solo footprints spell, ima be honest, it adds not a huge amount in terms of value if any, especially on a hat like this. Personally id say its completely fine to price using a sale with it.

Cases where it being spelled being a huge involvement in pricing would the eerie anger with matching spell, but pricing using spelled hats is quite common.

A few examples I could find in a few minutes-

https://backpack.tf/suggestion/64e3fe6916b63da8dd0f27ee

https://backpack.tf/suggestion/64524264720b16e4b9066e02

https://backpack.tf/suggestion/652c3c07a497ccdbdb03122c

Yeah I know they are common to do, one of those suggestions is mine. The only problem there is with this one that those didn't have is that there is a non-spelled one in the market with recent sales, those suggestions were accepted given that the non-spelled versions had no sales and had not been traded for a long time. I'm not sure if this case is special and the spelled version can be used but I'm more inclined to say no given rules unfortunately.

The burning flames company man got priced using the non spell sale, 3 spelled sales were overlooked.

There are also spelled and non spelled sales here. The spelled sale here should be overlooked if we’re going to be consistent.

That is true though in cases like this where spells mean very little to value id say a mods comment is probably needed.

Also for sale 6 it also includes the tesla toad and 200 keys

that brings that sale to 200 + toad + hkc + stove, even at buyers making this sale 560 keys making it supportive of the 650~

Also I disagree with you here. Burning company man sold for 200 keys unspelled, 308 with rofp and 340 with cgfp

spells add value, the spelled cloudy cm is worth more than non spelled.

the 340 was a clear outlier aswell as 300 given 2 sales at 200, the difference within this suggestion being that its not the only sale in the range that supports this price.

i can confirm i bought spelled for 480 pure and sold for 650 mixed

Would be helpful if you posted screenshots of the purchase of 480